Nancy's Pizza Menu (Updated September 2025)

Welcome to Nancy's Pizza, a hidden gem in O'Fallon that brings the authentic taste of Chicago-style deep-dish pizza right to your neighborhood. Nestled at 2007 State Hwy K, this pizzeria has quickly gained a reputation for its remarkable pies, both deep-dish and thin-crust. The menu offers a delightful range of options, from hearty appetizers like Loaded Waffle Buffalo Blue Fries to flavorful pastas including the classic Fettuccine Alfredo.

What sets Nancy's apart is their signature Stuffed Deep Dish Pizza. Each slice boasts a buttery crust, rich marinara, and generous portions of cheese that perfectly meld together. Customers rave about the freshness and savory flavors that transport them back to the Windy City’s culinary scene. As one patron noted, the pizza's crust, sauce, and cheese create a harmonious union that exceeds expectations.

The commitment to excellent customer service echoes in every review. Whether you're picking up your order or conversing with friendly staff, the experience is warm and inviting. Whether you try the classic or opt for a custom creation, Nancy's Pizza in O'Fallon is a must-visit for pizza lovers. Your taste buds will thank you!